Indestructible Dog Toys For Pit Bulls
Published: Last updated: by Jessi Larson Affiliate Disclosure: We hope you love the products we've recommended! As an Amazon Associate we earn a small share from qualifying purchases.Wimpy toys won’t work for a strong, strapping dog like the Pit Bull. This list of the top 15 indestructible dog toys for Pit Bulls is exactly what you need if your Pitty loves to pull apart its toys.
The products on this list have been specifically designed for dogs like yours who don’t play nicely with their toys. Instead, these dogs seek to destroy!
Although this is incredibly frustrating, you’re not alone. Many Pit Bull owners report this problem.
And it’s not just an issue for Pit Bulls. Many other types of dogs do the same thing.
We speak from experience. Our 110-lb Labrador Retriever Toby annihilates almost every toy he gets. That’s why we can confidently say the products below will stand up to strong chewers.
Indestructible Dog Toys For Pit Bulls: Our Top 15 Picks
From extra strong chew toys to ultra durable dog balls to soft but virtually undestroyable stuffed animals, our list has something for every Pitty out there!
The following indestructible dog toys for Pit Bulls are designed to stand up to these hearty hounds.
1. BarkBox Super Chewer
At the top of our list of indestructible dog toys for Pit Bulls is the Super Chewer box from BarkBox.
This monthly delivery box includes tough dog toys and treats that are selected specifically for chewers. Every box comes with two tough toys, two full-size bags of treats and two meaty chews.
We reviewed the box earlier this year with our dog. He put in some heavy chew sessions and made a dent in the toys but they still survived!
Why we like it:
- You get a special delivery every month with new toys and treats
- Unlike the traditional BarkBox, the Super Chewers option is designed for tough-chewing canines
- The service is backed up by industry-leading customer service
Check it out
2. KONG Xtreme or Classic
Toughest Natural Rubber, Black - Fun to Chew, Chase and Fetch - for Large Dogs
The KONG rubber toy is a gift from the heavens for anyone who has an energetic dog who needs some stimulation.
The concept is quite simple: You fill the inside of the KONG with things like peanut butter, treats, dog food, and so on, and your dog has to work hard to get it out.
Fortunately, the KONG is made from ultra-durable materials that stand up to the toughest chewers if they get aggressive when removing the treats.
We firmly believe that all pup parents should purchase this product!
Why we like it:
- It helps with boredom, teething, chewing, separation anxiety, digging, barking and so much more
- Sizes range from XS-XXL, depending on how big your dog is
- KONG is one of the most reputable dog toy manufacturers in the world
Fun tip: For an added challenge, you can add fillings to the KONG and freeze it ahead of time so your Pit Bull will have to work even harder for the treat.
3. Chuckit! Ultra Ball
Does your Pit Bull make mincemeat out of the traditional tennis ball?
If yes, you’re not alone. While tennis balls are a staple pet toy, they just don’t hold up to canines with extra tough teeth.
Instead, choose a Chuckit! Ultra Ball. These balls have a thick rubber core for aggressive chewers, yet they’re super soft on a dog’s mouth.
We can attest to their durability. Our behemoth dog destroys tennis balls in 60 seconds or less. However, we still have the original Chuckit! ball we bought him over six years ago. Talk about a good investment!
This is definitely a must-have when it comes to indestructible dog toys for Pit Bulls.
Why we like it:
- The textured surface and thick rubber core help it stand up to the toughest chewers
- The ball bounces and floats thanks to its lightweight, buoyant design
- The bright colors help keep dogs engaged
4. Zogoflex Zisc Tough Flying Disc
High Flying Aerodynamic Disc – Lightweight, Floatable Disc for Fetch, Tug of War, Catch, Play – Doubles as Food/Water Bowl, Large 8.5"
Frisbees are another quintessential dog toy. But unfortunately, most frisbees are flimsy and don’t work for dogs who like to chew.
Don’t despair – the Zogoflex Zisc Frisbee is an extra durable option that stands apart from the competition.
This frisbee is incredibly strong, but at the same time, it’s soft enough to be gentle on a dog’s mouth and keep their chompers safe and healthy.
It can fly through the air, bounce, roll, and, yes, even be chewed.
As an added bonus, the manufacturer even provides a 100% guarantee against dog damage. That’s quite the offer!
Why we like it:
- It flies like a hard plastic frisbee but is soft on a dog’s mouth
- You can choose a small or large size and pick from multiple colors
- If your dog does damage it, you can contact the manufacturer for a replacement
5. Tuffy Stuffed Elephant
Talk to any Pit Bull parents, and they’ll tell you that stuffed toys are destined to be destroyed by their vigorous dog.
But there’s hope! Tuffy makes stuffed toys that are MUCH stronger than others on the market.
Featuring a rating scale, these toys are differentiated by their much tougher stitching and fabric. They’re not completely indestructible, but if you keep an eye on them, they have a pretty decent chance of surviving for so much longer than the run-of-the-mill stuffed toy. Like months and even years versus minutes.
Our favorite is the stuffed elephant. It’s large and strong and presents a challenge for even the most persistent pups.
Why we like it:
- Tuffy toys have up to four layers of material and up to 7 rows of stitching for extra durability
- They also include an additional black webbing around the outside edge, which covers and protects the seams
- Your Pit Bull won’t be left out and can enjoy stuffed toys like other dogs!
6. Goughnuts Indestructible Chew Toy MAXX
Why does it seem like some dogs like to chew and chew and chew?
Many dogs may have a super strong desire to chew, and that’s perfectly natural, given their animal instincts. But what’s not cool is when they turn to furniture, shoes, socks, and other undesired items.
As a fix, give your Pit Bull a Goughnuts Indestructible Chew Toy MAXX. Simple and straightforward, it’s basically an oblong rubber stick that’s incredibly durable and long-lasting.
People who’ve purchased it have reported that their dogs have chewed on it for months without even making a dent.
Why we like it:
- GoughNuts Sticks are guaranteed for life
- The stick is being used by Police K9 units around the world
- The visual safety indicator appears when a dog has chewed too far
7. KONG Xtreme Rubber Ball
Durable Rubber Dog Toy for Power Chewers, Black - for Medium/Large Dogs
Is it a ball? Is it a treat holder? The KONG Xtreme Rubber Ball is both!
As you search for indestructible dog toys for Pit Bulls, definitely put this one on your list. The ball features a hollowed-out center for holding food, so you can play fetch, use it as a food puzzle, or all of the above.
Best of all, the durable construction creates a puncture-resistant outside for long-lasting use.
Why we like it:
- No need to decide between buying a ball, food puzzle, or chew toy – it’s all three!
- The extra bounce makes playing with the ball a ton of fun
- Again, we can’t speak highly enough of the KONG brand
8. Nylabone Dura Chew
Nylabone is another great brand that we love. Their products come in a variety of shapes and flavors and have excellent durability, making them nearly indestructible dog toys for Pit Bulls.
While we recommend all the Nylabone options, it might be a good idea to start with the Wishbone Chew Toy. The shape provides ample chewing opportunities for tough-toothed dogs.
These long-lasting, durable dog chew toys can help fight destructive behaviors, reduce stress and anxiety, decrease boredom, and care for your canine’s teeth.
Why we like it:
- The tough, durable nylon bone keeps powerful chewers busy
- Bristles help clean teeth and control plaque and tartar
- They have options ranging from XS to XXL
9. KONG Tires Xtreme Dog Toy
Durable Rubber Dog Toy & Treat Dispenser for Power Chewers - Medium/Large Dogs
Up next on our guide to indestructible dog toys for Pit Bulls is the KONG Tires Xtreme Dog Toy.
The Kong Tire is made with a durable rubber that should keep light to medium chewers at bay. Reviews suggest it may pass the grade for most dogs, although some aggressive chewers may get into it.
The tire comes in a small or large size, and you can use the inside to add some peanut butter or other filling to keep your pup occupied.
Why we like it:
- The natural KONG Xtreme black rubber formula is designed to stand up to determined dogs
- Sidewalls are designed to double up and rebound when compressed to provide an active chewing experience
- Strong and bouncy, the tires also work well for a game of fetch
10. Goughnuts Dog Chew Ring
Virtually Indestructible Dog Toys for Medium Breeds Such as Pit Bulls and German Shepherds | Heavy Duty Dog Toy | Green
What do you get when mechanical and polymer engineers team up to create a virtually indestructible chew toy? The Goughnuts Dog Chew Ring!
In addition to serving as a chew toy, this product also floats and can be used for fetch.
The cool thing about Goughnuts toys is that they have an inner red layer that is meant to alert you if the dog is starting to break it apart. If that happens, they’ll replace your toy with a new one for free!
Why we like it:
- You can use the ring as a chew toy or for playing tug of war, fetch, and more.
- Goughnuts guarantees their toys and will send a replacement if needed
- Multiple colors are available
11. Dog Rope Toys for Aggressive Chewers
Set of 11 nearly indestructible dog toys-bonus giraffe rope toys-benefits nonprofit dog rescue.
Rope toys are another furball favorite. Unfortunately, many can shred quickly, leaving behind a ball of thread.
Rest assured that this option from KILIKI is not one of those wimpy rope toys. It’s specifically designed for large, aggressive chewers and is nearly indestructible.
At three feet long, the rope features not one, not two, but five knots, guaranteeing the design is heavy-duty and durable!
Why we like it:
- It’s much larger and stronger than the average rope toy
- You can use it to play tug of war with your Pit Bull – a fun bonding activity!
- Believe it or not, the rope cleans a dog’s teeth and helps maintain good oral hygiene.
12. Monster K9 Ultra-Durable Chew Toy
Virtually Indestructible Dog Toys for Large Dogs, Heavy Duty Strong Tough Chew Toy for Aggressive Chewers Medium & Large Breed, Made in USA
Continuing our guide to indestructible dog toys for Pit Bulls, here is another ultra-tough option for this hulk of a hound.
Virtually indestructible, the Monster K9 Ultra-Durable Chew Toy is made from the toughest industrial-strength natural rubber. It’s designed to absorb shock and resist punctures, which is perfect for a Pitty.
The ring shape makes it a great chew toy, and you can also use it to play fetch or tug of war.
Why we like it:
- Monster K9 reports that only 1% of customers have had dogs who’ve chewed through the toy
- The company does, however, offer a lifetime money-back guarantee if that happens
- The versatile design keeps dogs entertained for hours
13. EETOYS Dog Chew Toy for Aggressive Chewers
Heavy Duty Dog Toy for Small, Medium, Large Dogs and Teething Puppies (6.69 inches)
Bones are great for dogs who love to chew. The only problem is that they often rip through them in a matter of minutes.
Making matters worse, real dog bones cost a pretty penny, and if you’re not careful, this could break your budget.
Instead, opt for a bone-shaped chew toy. The EETOYS Dog Chew Toy for Aggressive Chewers is an excellent option. It’s made out of non-toxic polymer nylon that’s virtually indestructible.
And if your dog misses the taste of real bones, don’t worry – the toy is flavored, and you can also lather on a thin layer of peanut butter for prolonged play.
Why we like it:
- The toy relieves excessive energy, reduces stress, and helps clean their teeth in the process
- It’s a much more affordable alternative to real dog bones
- The manufacturer will replace the toy in the rare case it gets damaged
14. Petstages Dogwood Wooden Dog Chew Toy
The Petstages Dogwood Wooden Dog Chew Toy is another option for dogs who love to constantly chew.
With all the taste and texture of real wood, the doggy chew satisfies your dog’s natural chewing instincts and is a tough, safe, and non-toxic alternative to wooden sticks.
Our dog Toby loved to chew on real sticks outdoors, but we quickly realized this wasn’t safe. Shards of the stick would splinter off, and he’d cut his mouth or swallow them and get sick.
We opted instead for the faux version from Petstages, and the toy is still intact today, over six years later.
Why we like it:
- It’s a much safer, long-lasting alternative to real sticks
- The stick is available in four different sizes, depending on your dog’s needs
- You can choose from original or mesquite flavors
15. Monster K9 Ultra-Durable Football Chew Toy
Pup parents with a destructive chewer can attest that most football toys are much too fragile for their furbaby. And those soft Nerf footballs? Forget about it!
The Monster K9 Ultra-Durable Football Chew Toy, however, is made specifically for these types of dogs.
In fact, it’s been tested with Pit Bulls and proved to stand up to their tough teeth.
How?
The products are designed with industrial-strength rubber that is shock-absorbent and blocks punctures.
Why we like it:
- The football shape is great for playing fetch
- The company offers a lifetime guarantee
- It’s one of the only football toys designed specifically for aggressive chewers like the Pit Bull
Why Do You Need Indestructible Dog Toys For Pit Bulls?
Pit Bulls originated in England in the early 19th century when bulldogs and terriers were crossbred to create a strong and agile canine.
Today, the term Pit Bull is used to loosely describe a type of dog with a physical appearance resembling a”bully-type” breed. Formal breeds in the Pill Bull category include the American Pit Bull Terrier, American Staffordshire Terrier and American Bully, and Staffordshire Bull Terrier.
Typically, a Pill Bull has a wide skull, strong facial muscles, and a strong jaw. They also are prone to bite, hold and shake items in their mouth.
Knowing this, it’s no wonder why Pit Bulls need tough dog toys like the ones on this list!
Getting a New Dog?